"Rent is throwing money away" is the most repeated line in real estate, and it's wrong. So is its mirror image, that buying is a trap for anyone who can rent cheaper. Both miss the same thing. The honest comparison isn't monthly rent against a monthly mortgage payment. It's what you'd be worth after a number of years down each path. That depends mostly on two things nobody can know in advance: how fast prices grow, and how long you stay.
What a fair comparison looks like
The calculator gives both paths the same starting cash and the same monthly budget:
- The buyer spends the down payment and closing costs on day one. From then on they pay the mortgage, property tax, strata, maintenance and insurance.
- The renter puts that same day-one cash into investments. Each month they pay rent and invest whatever the buyer is paying above that. If renting ever becomes the more expensive option, the buyer invests the difference instead.
At the end, the buyer sells. The buyer's net worth is the home's value, minus the selling costs and the remaining mortgage, plus any investments. The renter's net worth is the investment account. That's the only apples-to-apples way to compare them. Anything that looks at monthly payments alone leaves out appreciation, the principal you pay down, what your cash could earn elsewhere, and the cost of buying and selling.
The number that decides it: price growth
In the default scenario, a $699,000 two-bedroom condo against renting a comparable unit at $2,850, here's where you'd stand after ten years at different rates of price growth:
| Price growth per year | Buyer's net worth | Renter's net worth | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0% | $206,786 | $338,087 | renting ahead by $131,302 |
| 1% | $277,997 | $341,578 | renting ahead by $63,581 |
| 2.5% | $397,425 | $347,179 | buying ahead by $50,247 |
| 4% | $533,664 | $353,249 | buying ahead by $180,415 |
The break-even point on those numbers is about 1.86% a year. If prices grow faster than that over the decade, buying wins. If they grow slower, renting and investing wins. The calculator works out that break-even rate for whatever you enter. It's the most useful single number on the page, because you can hold it up against your own view of the market.
And the market has recently been much weaker than most people assume. As of June 2026, Greater Vancouver's composite benchmark price was up only about 7.7% over ten years, which is well under 1% a year. It was down 8% over three years. In August 2026 the apartment benchmark was $686,200, down 6.6% from a year earlier. Townhouses tell a different story over the same decade: up about 59% in the ten years to May 2026. That's a reminder that "the market" isn't one number, and neither is anyone's forecast. The honest approach is to run the calculator at a growth rate you'd be comfortable living with even if it turns out to be optimistic.
Time is the second lever
Buying and selling are expensive, and those costs don't depend on how long you stay. Going in, you pay property transfer tax (less the first-time buyer exemption, if you qualify), legal fees and an inspection. Coming out, you pay commission plus GST on it, and legal fees. On the default condo, the sale after ten years costs about $29,400.
Short stays don't have time to earn those costs back. At 2.5% price growth, the renter is ahead by about $25,400 after three years and by about $6,500 after five. Buying pulls ahead in year six. The break-even price growth also falls the longer you stay:
| Years you stay | 3 | 5 | 7 | 10 | 15 | 20 | 25 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Break-even price growth | 3.69% | 2.68% | 2.23% | 1.86% | 1.52% | 1.26% | 1.01% |
If there's a real chance you'll move for work, family or a bigger place within three or four years, the case for buying rests on a strong market. At ten years or more, it only needs a modest one.
Unrecoverable costs: the fairer monthly comparison
Comparing rent to a mortgage payment is misleading, because part of the mortgage payment is principal, and that's money you keep. The better comparison is money you don't get back.
For a renter, that's rent. For an owner, it's mortgage interest, property tax, strata fees, maintenance and insurance, plus the return the down payment and closing costs could have earned if they'd been invested instead.
On the default condo, those unrecoverable costs come to about $3,617 a month at the start. Renting the comparable unit costs $2,875 including tenant insurance, so owning is about $742 a month more expensive on this measure.
What closes that gap is appreciation. At 2.5% a year on a $699,000 home, that's about $17,500 in the first year, or roughly $1,460 a month. It's also why the answer swings so hard with price growth.
A version of this idea has become a popular rule of thumb in Canadian personal finance. It estimates an owner's unrecoverable costs as a set percentage of the home's value and compares that with rent. The calculator's stacked bars do the same thing with your actual numbers instead of a flat percentage.
The renter's side only works if the money actually gets invested
The comparison assumes the renter invests the full difference every month, which is $1,631 in the first month of the default scenario, and never touches it. In real life plenty of renters don't. Holidays, a nicer car, or just a looser budget absorb the difference.
If the default renter invested the starting $76,530 but spent the monthly difference, they'd have about $124,700 after ten years. The buyer would have $397,425. The forced savings of a mortgage are a real advantage for anyone who isn't going to be disciplined about investing. Be honest with yourself about which one you are.
Where the money is invested matters too. Growth inside a TFSA or FHSA isn't taxed, and a principal residence isn't either. Growth in a taxable account is. Switch the calculator to "taxable account" and the renter loses about a point a year to tax. On the default numbers, that drops the break-even price growth from 1.86% to about 1.56%.
BC rent control and the tenant who stays put
In BC, a landlord can raise rent on an existing tenancy only once a year, and only by the provincial cap. The cap is set to inflation: 2.3% for 2026 and 2.2% for 2027. A tenant who stays in the same unit for years ends up paying well below market, which works in renting's favour in this comparison.
There are two catches:
- The cap only protects you while you stay in the same unit. Move, and you pay whatever the market rent is at the time. Some tenancies also end because the owner or a close family member moves in, which BC allows with notice and compensation.
- Market rents move on their own. They've been falling. Average asking rents in BC were down about 4.5% year over year in the latest provincial figures. But they rose sharply through 2022 and 2023.
The calculator's default of 2.5% a year sits between the current cap and a long-run market average. Set it lower if you plan to stay in one place, and higher if you expect to move and rents to recover.
What the default scenario looks like
The default is a $699,000 two-bedroom condo, close to Metro Vancouver's apartment benchmark. It's bought by a first-time buyer with 10% down at 4.34%, with a $450 strata fee. The alternative is renting a comparable two-bedroom for $2,850.
Up front, the buyer needs $76,530. That's $69,900 down, about $3,980 of transfer tax after the first-time buyer exemption, and $2,650 in legal fees, title insurance and inspection. The CMHC premium is added to the mortgage, as it always is.
In the first month, the buyer pays $4,506 in total and the renter pays $2,875. Each year after that, the renter's costs rise with rent. The buyer's mortgage payment stays flat, while the strata fee, tax and upkeep rise.
Two changes move this scenario a lot:
- A higher comparable rent. At $3,200 instead of $2,850, buying is ahead by about $110,000 after ten years, and the break-even price growth falls to about 1.05%.
- A higher mortgage rate at renewal. The calculator holds your rate constant, so if you expect renewal rates to be higher, enter a higher rate to see the effect.
Getting the rent number right
The rent you enter matters almost as much as the price growth, and it's the easiest one to get wrong. Compare the home you'd buy with a rental that's genuinely similar: the same number of bedrooms, a similar size, the same neighbourhood, and ideally a similar building age.
Regional averages are a useful sanity check, but they mix very different homes. For September 2026, liv.rent put the average newly listed unfurnished one-bedroom across Metro Vancouver at about $2,085. The same report put a two-bedroom in Surrey at about $2,112. One listing service put the median two-bedroom asking rent in the City of Vancouver at about $3,300 in August 2026.
The best source is rentals in the same building or on the same block. On EstateBlock you can look at recent sales and current listings nearby. For rents, search the building's address on the rental sites and look at what similar units are actually leasing for, not the first asking price.
Be careful with the unit you currently rent. If you've been in the same place for years, BC's rent cap may have kept your rent well below market. That's a real advantage of staying put, but it isn't the rent you'd pay if you moved. Use your current rent if you'd genuinely stay there. Use the market rent if you'd be moving anyway.
Renting where you live and buying somewhere else
Some people split the decision. They keep renting in the neighbourhood they want to live in and buy a cheaper property elsewhere as an investment. It can make sense, but in BC it changes several of the numbers on this page.
- No first-time buyer exemption. It only applies to a home you live in, so you'd pay the full property transfer tax.
- A bigger down payment. A rental you won't live in needs at least 20% down, and usually carries a slightly higher rate.
- Taxable rent and gains. Rental income is taxed, and when you sell, the gain is taxable because the principal residence exemption doesn't apply.
- Local taxes. In some areas, BC's speculation and vacancy tax and Vancouver's empty homes tax apply if the unit isn't rented or lived in.
- The home flipping tax. Selling within two years can trigger it.
None of that rules the strategy out, but it's a different calculation. Our investor guide and investor tax calculator cover it.
Tax differences worth knowing
Your principal residence is exempt from capital gains tax when you sell. Most renters invest through a TFSA or FHSA first, which puts the two paths on equal footing. The FHSA is especially useful because it works either way. If you end up buying, it helps with the down payment. If you don't, it can be moved into an RRSP.
Once a renter's contributions spill over into a taxable account, the tax on that growth tilts the comparison toward buying.
BC also has a renter's tax credit of up to $400 a year for low- and moderate-income renters, which is small but real.
What the math can't price
Some of the biggest reasons people buy or rent never show up in a spreadsheet.
In favour of owning:
- Control. You can renovate, have pets and set up the place how you want.
- Security against a landlord selling or moving in.
- A fixed payment for the term.
- For families, the certainty of a school catchment.
In favour of renting:
- Freedom to move for a job or a relationship without a transaction.
- No special levies. A single envelope repair in an older strata can cost owners tens of thousands.
- No exposure to a falling market, which Metro Vancouver owners have lived through since 2022.
- No single large bet sitting on one building.
Leverage works in both directions. A 10% down payment on a home that falls 10% in value is wiped out on paper, even though your monthly payment hasn't changed. The table above shows how fast outcomes spread apart when price growth changes.
Mistakes we see in the rent vs buy decision
Comparing rent with the mortgage payment. Part of the payment is savings. Compare rent with unrecoverable costs instead.
Assuming prices always rise. The Metro Vancouver composite gained less than 1% a year over the decade to mid-2026. Plan with a growth rate you'd accept being wrong about.
Ignoring the cost of getting out. Commission, GST on the commission and legal fees on a $900,000 sale come to roughly $29,000. Short stays rarely earn that back.
Assuming the renter invests every dollar saved. If that isn't how you actually behave, the comparison flatters renting.
Forgetting strata risk. Fees rise faster than inflation in many buildings, and special levies aren't in anyone's monthly budget.
Using a rent figure for a different kind of home. Compare like with like: the same size, area and building type.
Questions people ask us
Is it better to rent or buy in Vancouver in 2026?
It depends on how long you'd stay and how fast you think prices will grow. For a $699,000 condo against renting a similar unit at $2,850, buying comes out ahead over ten years only if prices grow faster than about 1.86% a year. Over five years it needs about 2.68%, and over three years about 3.69%. Use the calculator with your own numbers.
How long do I need to own a home for buying to beat renting?
In the default scenario with 2.5% annual price growth, buying pulls ahead in year six. Transfer tax on the way in and commission on the way out take several years to earn back, so short stays usually favour renting unless prices rise quickly.
Is renting really throwing money away?
No more than mortgage interest, property tax, strata fees and maintenance are. Owners have unrecoverable costs too. On the default condo, they're about $3,617 a month at the start, compared with $2,875 in rent and tenant insurance. Whether owning wins depends on appreciation making up that difference.
How much can my landlord raise my rent in BC?
Once a year, by no more than the provincial cap, with three months' written notice. The cap is 2.3% for 2026 and 2.2% for 2027. It applies to existing tenancies, not to the rent set for a new tenant.
What investment return should I use?
Use a return you'd realistically expect after fees on a diversified portfolio, and be conservative. The calculator defaults to 5% a year. If the renter would invest in a taxable account rather than a TFSA or FHSA, select that option so the calculator allows for tax on the growth.
Does the calculator include the CMHC premium and property transfer tax?
Yes. The CMHC premium is added to the mortgage when you put down less than 20%. Property transfer tax is included with the first-time buyer exemption if you tick that box. Legal fees, title insurance and an inspection are included in the upfront cost, and commission plus GST and legal fees are deducted when you sell.
What if prices fall after I buy?
Then renting usually wins. At 0% annual growth over ten years, the default renter ends up about $131,000 ahead. That's the risk you accept in exchange for the chance of a gain and a stable home. Try the 0% option in the calculator to see your own downside.
Should I buy a smaller place now or keep renting and save for a bigger one?
Run both in the calculator. Enter the smaller home with the time you'd realistically stay in it, then add the cost of selling and buying again. If you'd move within three to five years, the transaction costs of two purchases often outweigh the gains from buying early.
778-918-5990
Want a straight answer for your situation?
Dan will walk through your numbers with you: the rent you'd actually compare against, what similar homes have sold for on your street, and what the strata documents say about upcoming costs. He'll also tell you if renting another year makes more sense. Your calculator inputs come along with the message.
Buying through EstateBlock? Ask about our buyer cashback rebate.
